Court upholds medical malpractice ruling in doctor-patient affair

Friday November 30, 2012

Does a doctor’s affair with a married patient constitute medical malpractice? Yes, according to a recent decision of a state court of appeals. However, the court also ruled, the patient shares the fault for the ongoing affair because of her willing participation in it.

According to court documents, the alleged medical malpractice began when the family doctor began to treat the patient for a gastrointestinal condition, followed by therapy sessions for anxiety and depression. It was during those sessions that the patient experienced “eroticized transference,” her personal injury attorney argued in court, with her emotions shifting toward the doctor.

Those shifting emotions ultimately resulted in an affair between the doctor and the patient, which lasted for about nine months and ended in 2002. The patient later told her husband about the affair, and he filed for divorce.

In 2005, the patient sued her former doctor, alleging that he committed medical malpractice by taking advantage of her emotions and starting the affair. The court agreed, awarding the patient $338,000 in damages. The doctor appealed the ruling.

Last week, the appellate court upheld the damages award, but ruled that the patient was 25 percent at fault for the affair and reduced the damages amount by that percentage. The court also threw out an additional $166,000 punitive damages award, finding that the doctor had committed no malicious conduct beyond the breach of his professional duty.

This is certainly not your standard medical malpractice case, but it is an interesting example of the wide spectrum of potential claims in this field. What do you think of it?

Source: Connecticut Post, “NY court says affair is medical malpractice,” Michael Virtanen, Nov. 29, 2012

Get in Touch

Schedule a Free Initial Consultation

At Kennedy, Johnson, Schwab & Roberge, L.L.C., we handle all cases on a contingency fee basis. This means that we do not get paid unless and until you receive a settlement or a jury award.

Schedule a free, confidential consultation with a skilled Connecticut personal injury lawyer today.

News & insights
The Negative Impact of Tailgating
Articles

The Negative Impact of Tailgating

9

August
2022

Common Causes of Construction Lawsuits
Articles

Common Causes of Construction Lawsuits

12

July
2022

The Leading Causes of Trucking Accidents
Articles

The Leading Causes of Trucking Accidents

12

July
2022

Medical Misdiagnosis: What Is It and How To Handle It
News

Medical Misdiagnosis: What Is It and How To Handle It

11

June
2022

The Role of Lack of Informed Consent in Medical Malpractice
Articles

The Role of Lack of Informed Consent in Medical Malpractice

11

June
2022

How to File a Medical Malpractice Lawsuit
Articles

How to File a Medical Malpractice Lawsuit

10

June
2022

Connecticut Auto Accident Laws to Be Aware Of
Articles

Connecticut Auto Accident Laws to Be Aware Of

9

June
2022

How Liability Is Determined for Defective Products
Articles

How Liability Is Determined for Defective Products

26

May
2022

The Most Common Personal Injury Cases
Articles

The Most Common Personal Injury Cases

24

May
2022

How a Pedestrian Accident Lawyer Can Help You
Articles

How a Pedestrian Accident Lawyer Can Help You

22

May
2022